NY Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew 13 May 2026 Prediction

New York Red Bulls, one of the weakest defensive teams in MLS, face Columbus Crew, which has won only once on the road so far. There is no clear favorite in this matchup, although the bookmakers give the visitors a slight edge. Should we follow that line?

New York Red Bulls

Last time out, New York Red Bulls pulled off a minor upset by beating Chicago Fire 3-1 on the road despite the pre-match odds. That was Michael Bradley’s team’s first MLS win in six matches. The Red Bulls’ main issue this season has been their defensive play. They have conceded 28 goals in 12 matches, an average of 2.33 per 90 minutes, compared to the league average of 1.61.

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew are in an even tougher spot. Ahead of the next round, the visitors sit only 12th in the Eastern Conference standings, three points outside the playoff zone. After two straight wins, the team has lost two games in a row and conceded six goals across those matches. Columbus has taken only four points from six road games.

New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew Prediction: New York Red Bulls Double Chance at 1.63

• Main Pick: After a strong result last time out, New York should have a good chance to build on that performance, especially against a suitable opponent. Columbus Crew have won only once in six away matches. It is also worth noting that the Red Bulls have lost just one of the last four head-to-head meetings. The pick is New York Red Bulls double chance at 1.63.
• Total Pick: This matchup should be open and eventful. New York’s home matches average four goals, while Columbus road games average 3.7 goals per 90 minutes. In three of the last five head-to-head meetings, the teams combined for at least four goals. We will take total over 3.5 at 2.26.